Paul Offit believes that they are.
In Philadelphia for example, the Hispanic population get vaccinated. This is because they trust their doctors and they trust doctors’ expertise. Not so with some within the upper class population. It is graduate school-educated, college-educated people who tend not to vaccinate, and that seems to be universally true.
Now – combine that with his view of parental health and medical decisions:
In the United States we balance the sovereign right of the parent to make a choice for the child against the right of the state to protect children. In some respects, we are far too slanted towards the rights of parents, and that is to the detriment of unvaccinated children and the larger community.
He isn’t saying that about all parents. Its the highly educated parents who, by thinking for themselves and selectively vaccinating, have Offit deeply concerned. He calls upon the government to compel full vaccination, by re-education if necessary:
I think the government should make it very tough to gain an exemption from a vaccination. To attempt to gain an exemption, a person should go through an educational program where they hear the information and the facts about vaccines and about the diseases they prevent.
Why does Paul Offit, a world-renowned expert on vaccines, believe that an unwilling public should be forced by government compulsion to vaccinate their children as directed by a faceless bureaucratic committee? Jacques Barzun, historian of ideas and culture, wrote that “science is an all-pervasive energy, for it is at once a mode of thought, a source of strong emotion, and a faith as fanatical as any in history.” [1] Simply put, he believes in vaccines. And because he is a world-renowned expert, you should trust him.
But we don’t think that way anymore. An ever-growing number of people are
- reading ingredient labels (for foods, household cleaners, soap, shampoo, even for vaccines)
- concerned about excessive use of pharmaceutical products (including antibiotics and vaccines)
- worried about toxins (like formaldehyde in school trailers or aluminum in vaccines)
- doing their best to reduce overall chemical exposure at every opportunity
We are taking charge of our own health and the health of our children. Medical doctors are, at best, consultants that offer one point of view for our consideration.
If public health officials want better compliance, then the first thing to do is to become, along with the pharmaceutical companies, more transparent and trustworthy. One way would be to toss out the intelligence-insulting campaigns such as “The Flu Ends With You” and stop recommending that everybody get the flu shot. Back in 1986, I had a terrible case of the flu and have been fine ever since – without a single flu shot. When the CDC tells me that I need a shot, which I clearly do not, they lose credibility.
[1] Barzun, Jacques (1964). Science: The Glorious Entertainment. p. 3